There has been fury on International Women’s Day as a Care Quality Commission report on NHS maternity services referred repeatedly to genderless ‘people’.
Campaigners have accused officials of not only downgrading a hospital trust found to be failing patients but also ‘dehumanising’ women with their choice of language.
The CQC announced it was dropping its overall rating for maternity services at Great Western Hospital in Swindon from ‘good’ to ‘needs improvement’ after an inspection.
But throughout its findings the commission often used the word ‘people’ when referring to those treated at the maternity unit – a choice critics called ‘enraging’.
At other times the word ‘women’ was used but most often in sentences such as ‘women, people using the service and their babies’.
Maternity services have been downgraded at Great Western Hospital in Swindon (pictured)
The Care Quality Commission’s report has been criticised for referring to genderless ‘people’
Announcing today’s downgrade, CQC’s deputy director of secondary and specialist healthcare Carolyn Jenkinson said there had been a deterioration in the level of care being provided to women, people using the service and their babies’.
Among the criticisms, she said: ‘People had experienced 3 and 4 degree perineal tears and bleeding during birth, but these had been downgraded in severity, which meant they were not investigated as thoroughly as they should’ve been to keep people safe.’
She went on to say: ‘We also found staff didn’t always assess people when they arrived or note how urgently they needed support.
‘This meant people weren’t always seen in order of clinical need and staff could miss if someone’s condition worsened.’
Trina Budge, director of campaign group For Women Scotland, responded by saying: ‘It’s just enraging. Men’s healthcare campaigns have no problem using clear language, but women are constantly dehumanised and reduced to body parts.
‘Clear language is really important in medical information but where women are concerned, this is forgotten.
‘There is a long history of misogyny in medicine and of women’s issues being ignored or overlooked – this is the latest iteration.’
There was also a backlash on social media, with one response on X, formerly Twitter, saying: ‘Every… single… person in the human race, in all of time was borne by a woman!’
The CQC’s deputy director of secondary and specialist healthcare Carolyn Jenkinson
There was fury on X, formerly Twitter, for the frequent use of ‘people’ in the CQC findings
Trina Budge, campaign group For Action Scotland’s co-director, called the language ‘enraging’
Someone else asked: ””People”? Are they not patients at minimum, and all who come through the doors of maternity wards to deliver a baby women?’
And many highlighted the ironic timing of International Women’s Day, such as: ‘”People’ – women give birth, women suffered this scandal. Do you think misogyny and sexism was involved? Happy #IWD24.’
Someone else wrote: ‘This happened to only one type of ‘people’ – women & only women. By hiding that fact you hide the problem & make fixing it harder. #IWD’
More responses included ‘#IWD only women give birth’ and ‘Oh, and so today is International Day of People do not mention the W word’.
It was also said: ‘Only women have perineums. Only women give birth.’
The report is the latest in a series of controversies over ‘gender-neutral’ phrasing, with NHS bodies themselves criticised for avoiding the words ‘women’ or ‘mothers’.
The NHS South Yorkshire Integrated Care Board was condemned this week as ‘scandalous and cowardly’ after advertising a role to support ‘birthing people’.
NHS Norfolk and Suffolk Foundation Trust posted on social media in August 2022 it was seeking ‘birthing people’ to provide feedback on its perinatal services.
Then-health secretary Steve Barclay ordered an investigation in February last year into new guidelines telling NHS staff to treat all patients as ‘gender-neutral’.
And MPs last August called for ministers to step in after 77 health trusts joined the NHS Rainbow Badge Scheme, which rewards them for dropping ‘gendered language’ from policies, forms and signs.
Other gender-neutral terms which have been introduced in the medical profession include ‘chestfeeding’, ‘second biological parent’, and ‘bonus hole’.
The CQC told MailOnline today: ‘Our inspection reports and ratings reflect our judgement of the services we visited and the evidence we review at the time of the inspection.
‘During our inspections we gather and review evidence from a range of sources including the experiences of staff and people receiving care and treatment.
‘We acknowledge that maternity services will be accessed by a wide range of people.
‘It’s therefore important that the language we use is appropriate, inclusive and sensitive to the needs of everyone.”
Post source: Daily mail
Content source – www.soundhealthandlastingwealth.com
